I’m Alan Chapell. Over the past 20+ years, I’ve been outside privacy counsel to hundreds of digital media companies and have brought over 40 of them to successful exits. I write a monthly syndicated report called The Chapell Regulatory Insider, and I’m also a regulatory analyst for The Monopoly Report.
The latest Monopoly Report podcast! This week, I welcome Madhavi Singh, Deputy Director of the Thurman Arnold Project and a Resident Fellow at the Information Society Project at Yale.

Kind of resembles the early 20th century stock market trajectory
Everyone Hates AI Slop
The never-ending, low-effort flood of cliched text, soulless images, and all-too-cute-but-otherwise-hapless memes continues to permeate our discourse here in adtech land. It’s not just on LinkedIn, or Slack, or on email. AI slop has fully crossed over into industry thought pieces and presentations.
We all seem to agree on the following:
It’s an inherently lazy means of communicating.
It seamlessly recounts the general idea while misstating the most salient points.
It’s horrible at nuance, framing, or the “big picture.”
So, great: AI is the hobgoblin of little minds and bad writing. We can’t trust it to write a good LinkedIn post. But when it comes to running the future of programmatic or generating bespoke audiences for ad targeting?
It’s like when Kramer from Seinfeld shared an idea for self-made pizza. Don’t worry. It’ll all be supervised!
On a related note, an increasingly large number of startups are very clearly using AI as a drafting tool for their privacy policies. Moreover, my panel of experts overwhelmingly believes that, by 2029, privacy policies will be mostly if not entirely written by AI. (Some luminaries even believe that might represent an improvement.)
While I get that this may come off as a bit self-serving, let me share why I think that current attempts to use AI to craft privacy policies is a really bad idea.
Imitation as the Sincerest Form of Flattery
Historically speaking, it has not exactly been uncommon for tech startups to use the good old “find and replace” method when drafting a privacy policy. In case you’re unfamiliar with the concept, allow me to elucidate.
Step 1 - Locate the policy of your nearest competitor.
Step 2 - Paste it into a word document.
Step 3 - Find every example of their company name.
Step 4 - Replace it with yours.
Step 5 - Post it on your site.
* Bonus points if you remember to change the company postal address.
I’m certainly not endorsing the find-and-replace approach - it also tended to be error prone. But the reasons that the find and replace approach “kind of” worked for the adtech community of yesterday were:
Adtech platforms were often relatively undifferentiated regarding the data they processed (which created its own set of challenges).
There were far fewer privacy rules to worry about.
I believe that both of the above have changed significantly in a relatively short period of time.
Like a Bad Combover, It’s Easy to Spot the AI
What are some of the tells when it comes to privacy policies written by AI? Here are just a few:
It denies collecting PII without defining PII—then lists advertising IDs, IP addresses, cookie IDs, mobile advertising IDs, and bidstream data.
It calls everything “anonymous” - Persistent identifiers, hashed emails, and device-level profiles are described as anonymous rather than pseudonymous. (Regulators and other privacy nerds hate it when you mix up those terms).
Its data-flow description could belong to any adtech - This may be a sign of a business model problem as much as a privacy problem.
It contains leftover chatbot instructions - Phrases like “insert your retention period,” or “tailor this section to your business” are unusually direct evidence of AI-assisted drafting.
It promises privacy controls that don’t exist - A fictional privacy dashboard, a nonexistent opt-out link or web form… or instructions to disable cookies in a mobile app.
It says “we never sell or share data”—then describes doing just that.
It makes stale cross-border data transfer references - Look for Privacy Shield or even Safe Harbor cited as a current transfer mechanism, or a mix of Privacy Shield and the EU-US Data Privacy Framework.
It describes third-party cookie deprecation as “imminent.” - (Although that just might be an example of a policy that doesn’t get updated very frequently.)
Donde esta, tu DPO? - It contains a named data protection officer (DPO) or EU representative who does not exist.
Human creation - It lacks the slightly uneven drafting based on years of frequent amendments.
I Am Not Bearish on the Use of AI
As an aside: Up until fairly recently, I was a touring musician. I used to get asked how I felt about tools like auto-tune. And before that, I’d get asked about the impact of recording tools like GarageBand and Pro Tools. Today, I’m often asked about AI slop in music. My answer is the same. Technology is often used to enable mediocrity. But those with talent and passion use those same tools to revolutionize.
I genuinely believe that’s the case for AI in the ads space. But it does need to be supervised by smart governance.
Part of problem with using AI to write a privacy policy is that it’s almost always done by one person. Usually, it’s the same person that’s in charge of your site’s CMP. And almost always, that person has very little understanding of the privacy rules.
And trust me: If I can tell that your policy is mostly AI generated, then there’s a good chance that the good people at CalPrivacy and other regulators can as well.
If there’s an area that you want to see covered on these pages, if you agree or disagree with something I’ve written, if you want to tell me you dig my music, or if you just want to yell at me, please reach out to me on LinkedIn or in the comments below.
This January, Marketecture is bringing a little old-school Vegas magic to CES, with a retro revival built for Ad Tech’s biggest week.
From branded content that keeps your CES story traveling into social-first video, exclusive Hot Takes sponsorships, and a happy hour with AdTechGod®, we’ve carefully designed standout opportunities that put your brand in the spotlight.
The house is open. Ready to make your mark?
Explore CES 2027 sponsorship opportunities below.
Marketecture Live IV Speakers and Early Bird Pricing are LIVE 👀
The room every marketer wants to be in is returning to New York City and now, we have our first look at who will be driving the conversations on stage this spring.
On March 9-10, 2027, Marketecture Live will be back at The Glasshouse NYC for a two-day event that will convene leading executives across brands, agencies, publishers, and adtech.
Wondering what the hype is all about? Marketecture Live takes a different approach: expertise first, no panels, no filler, no fluff. Across more than 40 sessions and breakouts, every conversation is designed to be sharp, relevant, and worth your time.
The event has consistently sold out, so don’t wait to lock in your ticket at the best price you’ll find.
Get to know our speakers and register today.
We're hiring for two (2) full-time roles to help us make an even bigger impact across the advertising ecosystem.
Know someone great? Send them our way! Think that's you? Check our Careers page and apply. We'd love to hear from you!







